Author Development
Reading Your Rejection Letter: What to Do Next
Editorial Office, Eleventh Press International Publishing™ 6 min read
A rejection usually means one of three things: the work is outside the journal's scope, the methodology has a fixable gap, or reviewers judged the contribution too incremental for the venue. Read the decision letter and reviewer comments together to tell which, triage every comment, revise before resubmitting elsewhere, and write to the handling editor only if a review contains a demonstrable factual error.
Top 10 key takeaways
- Rejection is a normal part of research publishing; most published papers have been rejected somewhere along the way.
- Decision types differ: desk rejection, rejection after review, reject-and-resubmit, and major or minor revisions each call for a different response.
- Read the editor's letter and the reviewer reports together; the editor's summary tells you which concerns were decisive.
- Most rejections fall into three categories: scope mismatch, a fixable methodological gap, or a contribution judged too incremental for the venue.
- Triage every reviewer comment into must-fix, should-address and disagree-with-reasons before deciding your next step.
- Evidence suggests papers resubmitted after rejection can go on to be cited at least as well as first-time acceptances, so feedback is worth acting on.
- Never resubmit a rejected manuscript elsewhere unchanged; reviewers overlap more often than authors expect.
- Never submit the same manuscript to two journals at the same time.
- Eleventh Press does not offer formal appeals for scope rejections, but you can ask the handling editor for a second read if a review contains a factual error.
- A clear, courteous, evidence-based reply serves you better than a combative one, whichever journal you go to next.
Is rejection normal?
Yes. Rejection is part of the ordinary life of research, not a verdict on the researcher. Selective journals reject the majority of what they receive, and most experienced authors have had papers rejected that were later published elsewhere and went on to be well cited. A study that traced the submission histories of tens of thousands of articles found that a substantial share had been rejected before finding a home, and that papers published after a rejection received, on average, more citations than those accepted at their first journal (Calcagno et al., 2012).
None of that makes a rejection pleasant. It is worth giving yourself a day before rereading the decision, because the most useful reading is the calm, analytical one.
What kind of decision did you receive?
Editorial decisions are not all the same, and the right next step depends on which one you have:
- Desk rejection: the editor declined the manuscript without external review, usually because of scope, a clear mismatch with the journal's article types or a fundamental problem visible at screening.
- Rejection after review: reviewers assessed the work and the editor concluded it could not be made suitable through revision.
- Reject and resubmit: the work is not acceptable in its current form, but a substantially revised version may be considered as a new submission.
- Major revisions: the manuscript may be acceptable if significant concerns are addressed; not a rejection, but not a guarantee either.
- Minor revisions: the manuscript is close to acceptable and needs specific, limited changes.
How do you decode the decision letter and the reviews?
Read the editor's letter first and then the reports, and look for the reasons the editor singles out. Reviewers may raise dozens of points; the editor's summary tells you which were decisive. Most rejections fall into one of three categories. A scope mismatch means the work does not fit the journal's aims, and no amount of revision will change that outcome there. A methodological gap — an underpowered sample, a missing control, an analysis that does not support the claim — is often fixable, and fixing it is worth doing before you submit anywhere else. A contribution judged too incremental means the reviewers did not see enough advance over existing work for that venue; sometimes that calls for a better-matched journal, and sometimes for a clearer statement of what is new.
Distinguish carefully between comments that identify a problem and comments that propose a solution. A reviewer who says “the statistical analysis is inappropriate; use a mixed model” may be right about the problem and wrong about the fix. Your obligation is to address the problem.
How should you triage reviewer comments?
Make a table with every reviewer comment in one column and three possible responses in the next: must fix (the comment identifies a real error or a gap any reader would notice), should address (the comment points to an improvement in clarity, framing or completeness), and disagree with reasons (you believe the comment is mistaken, and can explain why with evidence). The exercise turns an emotional document into a work plan, and it makes the decision about where to go next much clearer.
The same table becomes the basis of a response letter if you are invited to revise, or a checklist if you are resubmitting elsewhere. Noble's ten simple rules for responding to reviewers — among them, be polite, respond to every point, and make the changes easy to find — apply just as well to that internal exercise (Noble, 2017).
Where should you go next?
If the decision was a scope rejection, choose a journal whose aims and recent publications genuinely match the work, and say in your cover letter why it fits. If it was a fixable methodological concern, fix it first: reviewer pools overlap more often than authors expect, and a reviewer who sees the same unaddressed problem at a second journal is unlikely to be more forgiving. Update the literature review, reformat to the new journal's requirements and refresh the cover letter.
Two things to avoid. Never resubmit a rejected manuscript unchanged as though the review had not happened. And never submit the same manuscript to more than one journal at a time; simultaneous submission is a breach of publication ethics and wastes the time of editors and reviewers at both journals.
Can you appeal an Eleventh Press decision?
COPE expects journals to have a clear process for complaints and appeals, and ours is deliberately simple. We do not offer formal appeals for straightforward scope rejections, because scope is an editorial judgement about the journal rather than about the quality of the work. But if you believe a review contains a demonstrable factual error — it misreads a result, criticises an analysis you did not perform, or relies on a misunderstanding you can document — write to the handling editor, explain the specific error with evidence and ask for a second read.
The editor will consider the request and may consult another reviewer. A second read is not a renegotiation of every point, and it will rarely succeed if the disagreement is about interpretation rather than fact. Concerns about the conduct of the review process itself, as distinct from its outcome, can be raised with the editorial office, which handles them independently of the original editor.
How do you respond well, whatever you decide?
Courtesy is a strategy, not just a virtue. Editors remember authors, and a calm, evidence-based response — whether to a revision request, in a second-read request or in a new cover letter — is more persuasive than an aggrieved one. Thank reviewers for their time even when you disagree with them; it costs nothing and it signals that you have engaged with the substance.
Above all, treat the review as information. Even a rejection from a poorly matched venue usually contains two or three points that, once addressed, make the paper stronger wherever it is published next.
Frequently asked questions
What is a desk rejection?
A decision by the editor to decline a manuscript without sending it for external peer review, usually because it is outside the journal's scope or has a fundamental problem visible at screening.
Should I resubmit a rejected manuscript to another journal unchanged?
No. Address the reviewers' substantive concerns first. Reviewer pools overlap, and the same unaddressed problems are likely to be raised again.
Can I appeal a rejection from Eleventh Press?
There is no formal appeal for scope rejections. If a review contains a demonstrable factual error, you can write to the handling editor with evidence and request a second read.
Can I submit my manuscript to two journals at once?
No. Simultaneous submission breaches publication ethics. Wait for a decision, or formally withdraw the manuscript, before submitting elsewhere.
Is reject-and-resubmit the same as major revisions?
No. Major revisions continue the same submission; reject-and-resubmit closes it, and a substantially revised manuscript is treated as a new submission.
References
- Calcagno, V., Demoinet, E., Gollner, K., Guidi, L., Ruths, D., & de Mazancourt, C. (2012). Flows of research manuscripts among scientific journals reveal hidden submission patterns. Science, 338(6110), 1065–1069. doi.org/10.1126/science.1227833
- Committee on Publication Ethics. (2017). Core practices: Complaints and appeals. publicationethics.org/core-practices
- Noble, W. S. (2017). Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers. PLOS Computational Biology, 13(10), e1005730. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005730
- Silvia, P. J. (2019). How to write a lot: A practical guide to productive academic writing (2nd ed.). American Psychological Association.
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (n.d.). Recommendations for the conduct, reporting, editing, and publication of scholarly work in medical journals. www.icmje.org/recommendations/
Official guides on this topic
More from the blog
Dissemination & Open Scholarship
Beyond the DOI: Inside Our Multidisciplinary Syndication Network
7 min read
Books & Long-Form Scholarship
Your Articles, Now a Book: How Our Publishing Division Works
6 min read
Peer Review & Editorial Practice
Why Multidisciplinary Research Needs Its Own Editorial Standards
6 min read