Peer Review & Editorial Practice
Why Multidisciplinary Research Needs Its Own Editorial Standards
Editorial Office, Eleventh Press International Publishing™ 6 min read
Multidisciplinary manuscripts fail single-discipline review because no single reviewer can judge every component. Eleventh Press assigns discipline-matched reviewers to each component, applies the reporting guideline that fits each method, and asks the handling editor to synthesise the reviews and judge the integration itself — so cross-field work is evaluated on its own terms.
Top 10 key takeaways
- Multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary research differ in how deeply fields are integrated, and each needs a different kind of evaluation.
- Evidence shows interdisciplinary proposals and careers face systematic disadvantages in conventional evaluation, which a well-designed review process must counteract.
- Single-discipline checklists fail on cross-field manuscripts because no single reviewer can credibly assess every method and literature involved.
- Eleventh Press assigns discipline-matched reviewers to each substantive component of a manuscript rather than one generalist to the whole.
- Each component is assessed against the reporting guideline appropriate to its method, drawn from the EQUATOR Network library where one exists.
- Mixed-methods work is additionally judged on integration — how the strands combine — using criteria such as GRAMMS.
- The handling editor synthesises divergent reviews and makes a decision about the manuscript as a whole, not by counting votes.
- Authors can help by writing for the adjacent reader: define field-specific terms, justify methods to outsiders and state each field's contribution explicitly.
- Component-matched review takes longer than single-track review, and we accept that cost as the price of fair evaluation.
- Our twelve-discipline remit, from Physics to Language and Literature, exists because the most consequential research questions rarely respect disciplinary boundaries.
What makes research multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary or transdisciplinary?
The terms are often used interchangeably, but they describe different degrees of integration. Multidisciplinary research places several disciplines side by side, each contributing its own methods to a shared problem. Interdisciplinary research integrates concepts, data or methods from different fields into a framework none of them would produce alone. Transdisciplinary research goes further again, frequently involving non-academic partners and producing knowledge that transcends the contributing disciplines. The US National Academies' influential report on facilitating interdisciplinary research framed the distinction around integration of information, data, techniques, tools, perspectives, concepts and theories (National Academies, 2005).
For editors the distinction matters because it decides what has to be evaluated. A multidisciplinary paper can largely be assessed component by component. An interdisciplinary paper must also be assessed on whether the integration works: whether the climate model's assumptions are compatible with the epidemiological data it is coupled to, or whether the qualitative findings genuinely inform the quantitative design.
Is interdisciplinary work disadvantaged in conventional evaluation?
The evidence suggests that it often is. An analysis of research proposals submitted to the Australian Research Council found that the more interdisciplinary a proposal, the lower its chance of being funded (Bromham et al., 2016). A large study of researchers' careers found that interdisciplinary scientists were more visible but less productive by conventional publication counts, partly because integration takes time and partly because their work is harder to place (Leahey et al., 2017). Bibliometric work suggests interdisciplinary papers can take longer to accumulate citations even when their long-term impact is high (Wang et al., 2015).
Michèle Lamont's ethnography of funding panels describes why. Reviewers apply the standards of their own discipline, and work that does not fit those standards is easily read as weak rather than as different (Lamont, 2009). A journal that claims a multidisciplinary remit has to design its review process to counteract that tendency, not merely tolerate cross-field submissions.
Why do single-discipline checklists break down?
Most peer-review forms were written for a single discipline and then reused everywhere. They ask whether the methods are appropriate and the conclusions follow from the results, and they implicitly assume that one reviewer can answer both questions for the whole paper. Consider a manuscript that combines downscaled climate projections, a statistical model of heat-related hospital admissions and semi-structured interviews with municipal planners. A climate scientist is well placed to judge the projections, an epidemiologist the admissions model and a qualitative social scientist the interviews; it is rare for anyone to be expert in all three.
When a single generalist reviews such a paper, two failure modes are common. The reviewer may defer on everything outside their expertise, so parts of the work receive no meaningful scrutiny; or they may judge the unfamiliar parts by the conventions of their own field and reject sound work for the wrong reasons. Either outcome is unfair to authors and unhelpful to readers.
How does component-matched review work at Eleventh Press?
When a cross-field manuscript clears initial screening, the handling editor identifies its substantive components and matches a reviewer to each, using the manuscript's discipline tags and keywords against reviewers' declared expertise. Each reviewer is told which component they are primarily responsible for, invited to comment on the rest where they feel competent, and asked to state their confidence in their own assessment.
Each component is then assessed against the reporting standard that fits its method. The EQUATOR Network maintains a library of reporting guidelines — CONSORT for randomised trials, PRISMA 2020 for systematic reviews (Page et al., 2021), STROBE for observational studies, COREQ and SRQR for qualitative research, ARRIVE for animal research — and we point reviewers to the relevant ones. For mixed-methods studies we also ask reviewers to assess integration using criteria such as GRAMMS, the Good Reporting of A Mixed Methods Study framework (O'Cathain et al., 2008).
What is the editor's role when reviewers disagree?
Component-matched review produces reports that often pull in different directions: the climate reviewer may be satisfied while the qualitative reviewer asks for a deeper analysis. The handling editor's job is synthesis, not arithmetic. A decision is not reached by counting recommendations; it is reached by asking whether each component meets the standard of its own field and whether the integration delivers something none of the components could deliver alone.
Where reviews conflict on a matter of fact, the editor may seek an additional opinion. Where they conflict on a matter of disciplinary convention, the editor explains in the decision letter which convention applies to which part of the work, so authors receive a coherent set of revisions rather than contradictory instructions.
What does this cost, and why is it worth it?
Component-matched review is slower than single-track review. It needs more reviewers, more coordination and more editorial time, and finding qualified reviewers for an unusual combination of fields can take longer. We accept that cost deliberately.
Our twelve disciplines — from Physics, Biology and Computer Science to Economics, Education and Language and Literature — were chosen because the questions that matter most, such as climate adaptation, algorithmic governance, genomic medicine and urban inequality, sit across them. A press built for that research has to evaluate it on its own terms. The alternative, forcing cross-field work into a single discipline's checklist, is faster only because it is less fair.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary research?
Multidisciplinary research places several disciplines side by side on a shared problem; interdisciplinary research integrates their concepts, data or methods into a new framework. Interdisciplinary work must therefore also be evaluated on how well that integration works.
How many reviewers will a multidisciplinary manuscript receive?
Typically two or three, matched to the manuscript's substantive components. Where a paper has more components than that, the editor may invite additional reviewers or seek a specific opinion on one part.
Which reporting guidelines should I follow?
Follow the guideline that matches each method, using the EQUATOR Network library — for example CONSORT for trials, PRISMA 2020 for systematic reviews, STROBE for observational studies and COREQ or SRQR for qualitative work — and state which ones you used.
What happens when reviewers from different fields disagree?
The handling editor synthesises the reports, judges each component against its own field's standards, and explains in the decision letter which expectations apply to which part of the work.
References
- Bromham, L., Dinnage, R., & Hua, X. (2016). Interdisciplinary research has consistently lower funding success. Nature, 534(7609), 684–687. doi.org/10.1038/nature18315
- Lamont, M. (2009). How professors think: Inside the curious world of academic judgment. Harvard University Press.
- Leahey, E., Beckman, C. M., & Stanko, T. L. (2017). Prominent but less productive: The impact of interdisciplinarity on scientists' research. Administrative Science Quarterly, 62(1), 105–139. doi.org/10.1177/0001839216665364
- National Academy of Sciences, National Academy of Engineering, & Institute of Medicine. (2005). Facilitating interdisciplinary research. The National Academies Press. doi.org/10.17226/11153
- O'Cathain, A., Murphy, E., & Nicholl, J. (2008). The quality of mixed methods studies in health services research. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 13(2), 92–98. doi.org/10.1258/jhsrp.2007.007074
- Page, M. J., McKenzie, J. E., Bossuyt, P. M., et al. (2021). The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ, 372, n71. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n71
- Wang, J., Thijs, B., & Glänzel, W. (2015). Interdisciplinarity and impact: Distinct effects of variety, balance, and disparity. PLOS ONE, 10(5), e0127298. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0127298
- EQUATOR Network. (n.d.). Enhancing the QUAlity and Transparency Of health Research: Reporting guidelines library. www.equator-network.org/