Peer Review & Editorial Practice
A Plain-Language Guide to Double-Blind Peer Review
Editorial Office, Eleventh Press International Publishing™ 6 min read
In double-blind (double-anonymised) peer review, authors do not know who reviewed their work and reviewers do not know who wrote it. At Eleventh Press it is the default model: names, affiliations, acknowledgements, funding statements and file metadata are removed before a manuscript reaches reviewers, so the work is judged on its merits first. Single-anonymised or open review is offered where a field's norms make blinding impractical.
Top 10 key takeaways
- Double-blind review hides the authors' identities from reviewers and the reviewers' identities from authors; NISO's standard terminology calls it “double anonymized”.
- It is the default review model at Eleventh Press because it removes the most easily biased signals: name, institution, seniority and geography.
- Controlled evidence shows reviewers who can see author identities favour famous authors and prestigious institutions.
- Anonymisation covers more than the title page: acknowledgements, funding, self-citations, file names and document metadata all need attention.
- Self-citation is allowed in an anonymised manuscript when written in the third person, not removed.
- Blinding is imperfect: a niche dataset or a distinctive approach can reveal authorship, but the aim is to reduce bias, not to guarantee secrecy.
- Reviewers must not try to identify authors and must declare it to the editor if they recognise the work.
- Single-anonymised and fully open review are available where blinding is impractical or counterproductive, for example in some community-based research.
- Optional open peer review can publish reports alongside the article for authors who want the review history to be visible.
- Whatever the model, COPE's ethical guidelines for peer reviewers govern confidentiality, conflicts of interest and conduct.
What exactly is double-blind peer review?
Peer review models differ mainly in who knows whose identity. In single-blind (single-anonymised) review, reviewers know who the authors are but authors do not know who the reviewers are; this remains the most common model in many sciences. In double-blind (double-anonymised) review, neither side knows the other's identity. In open review, identities are known to both sides, and in some forms the reports themselves are published.
The publishing industry has moved towards more precise language. ANSI/NISO Z39.106-2023, the Standard Terminology for Peer Review developed with the STM association, describes these models in terms of identity transparency and uses “anonymized” rather than “blind”, partly to avoid ableist connotations and partly because it describes what actually happens to the manuscript. We use both terms in this article because “double-blind” is still what most researchers search for.
Why does hiding identities matter? What does the evidence say?
The case for double-anonymised review rests on evidence that reviewers are influenced by who wrote a paper, not only by what it says. In a controlled experiment at a leading computer-science conference, reviewers who could see author identities were significantly more likely to recommend acceptance of papers by famous authors and from top universities and companies than reviewers of the same papers who could not (Tomkins et al., 2017). A large field experiment in economics found that the same manuscript was far more likely to be accepted when attributed to a Nobel laureate than to an unknown early-career researcher (Huber et al., 2022). A randomised study in orthopaedics found reviewers rated a manuscript more favourably when they knew it came from prominent authors (Okike et al., 2016).
Reviews of the literature on peer review bias identify prestige, nationality, language, gender and institutional affiliation as recurring concerns, while noting the evidence is mixed on some of them (Lee et al., 2013). Double-anonymised review does not remove every source of bias, but it removes the cheapest and most visible signals before a reviewer forms a first impression.
What is removed from a manuscript before review?
Anonymisation is harder than deleting names from the first page. Before a manuscript reaches reviewers, the editorial office and the author together make sure that the following are removed or masked:
- Author names, affiliations, email addresses and ORCID iDs, which live on a separate title page rather than in the anonymised file.
- Acknowledgements and funding statements, which often name laboratories, supervisors or grant numbers; these are restored at production.
- Self-identifying references in the text (“in our previous work [12]”), rewritten in the third person (“Smith et al. [12] showed…”).
- Institutional names in the methods, such as the name of the hospital, school or ethics committee, replaced with neutral placeholders.
- File names and document properties — the author and organisation fields that word processors and PDF tools embed automatically.
- Identifying links, such as repository URLs or project websites; data can be shared through an anonymised review link where the repository supports one.
Self-citation is not prohibited. Removing every reference to one's own earlier work would weaken the manuscript and can itself give the game away. Cite your work as you would cite anyone else's.
What are the limits of double-blind review?
Blinding is imperfect. In a small field, a distinctive dataset, an unusual instrument or a recognisable line of argument can reveal who wrote a paper, and preprints make the full text of many submissions findable online. Studies of reviewers' ability to guess authorship report that a meaningful share of guesses are correct, especially in narrow subfields.
The goal, however, was never cryptographic anonymity. It is to make sure that a reviewer's first and dominant impression comes from the work rather than from the name on it, and to give reviewers an explicit norm: do not try to find out. Our Reviewer Handbook asks reviewers who recognise a manuscript to say so to the editor, so that the editor can decide whether the review can proceed fairly.
When is single-anonymised or open review more appropriate?
In some fields blinding is impractical or counterproductive. Community-based participatory research, for example, may be impossible to describe without identifying the partners involved, and some qualitative and practice-based work depends on the researcher's positionality, which is part of what reviewers need to assess. In those cases authors can choose single-anonymised review, or fully open review where both parties are known.
Open peer review is itself a family of practices — open identities, open reports, open participation and more — as Ross-Hellauer's systematic review showed (Ross-Hellauer, 2017). At Eleventh Press authors can additionally opt in to open peer review, in which the review reports are made public alongside the published article. Publishing reports adds transparency and gives reviewers' work visible credit; it is optional because not every author or reviewer is comfortable with it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between single-blind and double-blind peer review?
In single-blind review the reviewers know the authors' identities but not vice versa. In double-blind review neither side knows the other's identity.
Should I remove all citations to my own work?
No. Keep them, but write them in the third person (“Smith et al. showed…”) rather than “in our previous work”, and make sure the reference list does not mark them as yours.
How do I remove hidden metadata from my file?
Clear the author and organisation fields in your word processor's document properties or inspection tool before exporting, give the file a neutral name, and check the PDF properties if you upload a PDF.
Can I choose a different review model?
Yes. Double-blind is the default, but you can choose single-anonymised or open review at submission where your field's norms make blinding impractical, and you can opt in to publishing the review reports.
What should a reviewer do if they recognise the author?
Tell the handling editor, without trying to confirm the guess. The editor decides whether the review can proceed fairly or should be reassigned.
References
- Committee on Publication Ethics Council. (2017). Ethical guidelines for peer reviewers (Version 2). doi.org/10.24318/cope.2019.1.9
- Huber, J., Inoua, S., Kerschbamer, R., König-Kersting, C., Palan, S., & Smith, V. L. (2022). Nobel and novice: Author prominence affects peer review. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(41), e2205779119. doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2205779119
- Lee, C. J., Sugimoto, C. R., Zhang, G., & Cronin, B. (2013). Bias in peer review. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 64(1), 2–17. doi.org/10.1002/asi.22784
- National Information Standards Organization. (2023). Standard terminology for peer review (ANSI/NISO Z39.106-2023). doi.org/10.3789/ansi.niso.z39.106-2023
- Okike, K., Hug, K. T., Kocher, M. S., & Leopold, S. S. (2016). Single-blind vs double-blind peer review in the setting of author prestige. JAMA, 316(12), 1315–1316. doi.org/10.1001/jama.2016.11014
- Ross-Hellauer, T. (2017). What is open peer review? A systematic review. F1000Research, 6, 588. doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.11369.2
- Tomkins, A., Zhang, M., & Heavlin, W. D. (2017). Reviewer bias in single- versus double-blind peer review. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(48), 12708–12713. doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1707323114
Official guides on this topic
More from the blog
Dissemination & Open Scholarship
Beyond the DOI: Inside Our Multidisciplinary Syndication Network
7 min read
Books & Long-Form Scholarship
Your Articles, Now a Book: How Our Publishing Division Works
6 min read
Peer Review & Editorial Practice
Why Multidisciplinary Research Needs Its Own Editorial Standards
6 min read